ADVERTISEMENT

Are we supplementing our way to sleep?

From melatonin gummies to magnesium powders and ashwagandha capsules, sleep supplements are becoming the latest additions to our wellness routines. But are we treating sleeplessness, or are we just adding another supplement to the stack?

Harper's Bazaar India

A glass of warm milk before bed, a cup of chamomile tea, or counting sheep until you finally drift off: bedtime remedies have always existed. But somewhere along the way, the humble sleep routine got a wellness makeover. Now, getting eight hours of rest can involve a carefully timed gummy, a powder mixed into your evening drink, and a capsule to help you wind down. Even sleep has a supplement stack.

It's hardly surprising. Between late-night scrolling, demanding work schedules, and the general difficulty of switching off, a good night's sleep can feel increasingly elusive. And with wellness culture encouraging us to track, measure and optimise almost everything, sleep has become another thing we're trying to get right. But before turning bedtime into an elaborate ritual, it's worth asking what these products actually do.

The business of switching off

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by The Upside (@theupside.in)


Melatonin might be the most familiar name in the sleep supplement aisle, but it's not quite a sleeping pill. It's a hormone naturally produced by the brain when it gets dark, signalling that it's time to wind down and helping regulate our body clock. Taking it as a supplement can help when that internal clock is out of sync, but it isn't a fix for every kind of sleeplessness.

The category is now expanding beyond melatonin, with brands exploring formulations that focus on relaxation, stress, and recovery. Anusha Bhushan, founder of Upside, says people approach the brand with all sorts of sleep concerns, from waking up in the middle of the night to struggling to fall asleep or feeling unrested despite spending enough time in bed.

Upside has deliberately left melatonin out of its formulation. "We'd rather start with what's happening upstream when sleep struggles, such as stress, an overactive nervous system, or an irregular routine," says Bhushan. Instead, its formula combines amino acids, minerals, and botanical extracts intended to support relaxation and stress regulation. The brand suggests taking it consistently for a month before pausing to reassess, rather than making it a permanent fixture of the bedtime routine.

What's actually happening when we sleep?


Not every ingredient works in the same way. Magnesium supports normal nervous system function, while ashwagandha has been studied for its role in managing stress. L-theanine, an amino acid found in green tea, is associated with relaxation without necessarily making you drowsy. But just because an ingredient sounds promising doesn't mean every product containing it will deliver the same results.

Shradha Khanna, VP of nutrition and scientific marketing at Wellbeing Nutrition and a certified nutritionist, says the evidence varies considerably. While melatonin has stronger research behind it for issues such as jet lag and delayed sleep timing, its benefits for general insomnia are relatively modest. Magnesium's effectiveness for treating insomnia remains mixed, while research on ashwagandha for stress-related sleep difficulties is more encouraging. "The important distinction is between an ingredient's established physiological function and its clinically demonstrated impact on sleep," she says. In other words, a long ingredient list isn't necessarily a better one.

Are we fixing the problem or just masking it?


There's also the question of why we're not sleeping well in the first place. Nutritional therapist Richi Agarwal believes that while supplements can help people with specific nutritional deficiencies, they can't compensate for habits that keep the body on high alert. "No supplement can outwork a lifestyle that keeps the body on high alert," she says. In her practice, she often sees people arrive already taking multiple sleep products, without having experienced much improvement.

And taking more isn't necessarily better. The same ingredients can crop up across multivitamins, stress-support formulas and dedicated sleep products, making it easy to double up without realising. Combining supplements can also lead to interactions, particularly alongside certain prescription medications or alcohol. "My approach is always to introduce one supplement at a time and give it a few weeks," says Agarwal. Otherwise, it's difficult to tell what's helping and what's potentially causing an unwanted reaction.

The bigger concern is how easily supplementation can become a substitute for understanding persistent sleep difficulties. Stress, irregular eating patterns, caffeine habits, and hormonal changes can all play a role. Sometimes, the answer might be a more consistent bedtime, fewer late-night scrolls, or simply addressing what's keeping you awake. Perhaps it's time to stop treating sleep as another wellness project to perfect and let our bodies do what they're meant to do: rest.

Lead image: Pexels

Also read: The technologies changing how women live, work, and care for themselves

Also read: In-vitro vs in-vivo skincare testing: What do these claims actually mean?

ADVERTISEMENT