The female gaze versus the male gaze: Who gets to decide what's desirable?

Think beyond chiselled abs and picture-perfect heroines. The female gaze is making room for vulnerability, intimacy, and more nuanced ideas of desirability.

offline

For years, pop culture has had a fairly predictable idea of what makes a man attractive. Think chiselled abs, broad shoulders, a mysterious and intimidating personality, a brooding expression, and an almost effortless disregard for everyone around him. From Wolverine to a particularly ripped Shah Rukh Khan, the conventionally masculine leading man has long been presented as the ultimate romantic fantasy. And while there is absolutely nothing wrong with finding a muscular man attractive, the bigger question is whether this is the only version of desirability that cinema has allowed us to see. After all, women are not a monolith, and attraction rarely comes down to a single physical type. So why have we spent decades watching the same version of the desirable man and woman play out on screen?

This brings us to the male gaze versus the female gaze debate. The term 'male gaze' was popularised by film theorist Laura Mulvey in 1975. It describes how women have traditionally been framed through a heterosexual male perspective, often presented as objects of visual pleasure rather than individuals with their own desires, ambitions, and stories. And the female gaze attempts to shift that perspective by placing greater emphasis on emotional connection, agency, vulnerability, and the experience of desire itself. 


It is perhaps why Harry Styles, with his eccentric dressing and fluid approach to masculinity, Timothée Chalamet, who doesn't fit the traditional muscular leading-man mould, and Pedro Pascal, with his warmth and easy charm, have become such popular figures among women. The internet has even found a phrase for the phenomenon: 'men written by women'. But what does that really look like, and why are we seeing more of it?

The appeal of men who are 'written by women'

If social media has taught us anything, it is that women have a very long list of qualities they find attractive, and a six-pack isn't necessarily at the top of it. The 'men written by women' conversation is largely about fictional male characters who are emotionally intelligent, attentive, respectful, and comfortable expressing affection. They remember the little things, listen without turning everything into a competition, communicate instead of shutting down, and understand that vulnerability isn't a threat to their masculinity. Their personality does not end at their abs. They can be confident, ambitious, funny, vulnerable, and physically attractive, all at once. The difference is that their appeal isn't built entirely around how they look.


Recent television has given us several examples. In Nobody Wants This, Adam Brody's Noah is charming and confident, but his appeal also comes from his willingness to be affectionate, communicate, and make an effort to understand Joanne. Off Campus, meanwhile, gives us Garrett Graham, a conventionally attractive hockey player whose relationship with Hannah is built around trust, consent, and emotional understanding. The show also makes space for conversations around female pleasure, something mainstream romantic storytelling has often overlooked. 

Then there is Heated Rivalry, where Shane and Ilya's relationship explores longing, insecurity, and the difficulty of being emotionally vulnerable, even as both characters navigate their public personas as professional athletes.

The female gaze, however, isn't restricted to romance or men being particularly good partners. Bridgerton frequently allows its female characters to experience desire from their own perspective, with intimacy and pleasure becoming part of their individual journeys. Even outside romantic dramas, shows like Fleabag and Nobody Wants This demonstrate how much more interesting storytelling becomes when women are allowed to be flawed, funny, complicated, and occasionally unlikeable. Basically, more than just side characters for their male counterparts.


Of course, this doesn't mean that a muscular, traditionally masculine man cannot be part of the female gaze. Garrett in Off Campus is proof enough. Nor does a sensitive male character automatically make a film or show an example of it. The distinction lies in how the character is written, how the camera frames him, and whether the relationship makes room for both people's experiences. A man can be physically intimidating and emotionally available. Both can be attractive qualities.

It's also about how women are seen on screen

While the internet's fascination with emotionally available men makes for an entertaining conversation, the female gaze is ultimately about much more than the kind of men women want to date. It also asks how women are represented, whose desires are being acknowledged, and whether female characters have an identity beyond their physical appearance. A woman can be glamorous, sensual, confident, and unapologetic about her sexuality without being reduced to an object of desire. The difference often lies in whether she has agency over her own portrayal and whether the camera is interested in her perspective, too.

The recent Janhvi Kapoor Peddi controversy brought this conversation back into focus. Viewers criticised the way her character, Achiyamma, was written and filmed, with several taking issue with repeated close-up shots of her waist and navel and romantic scenes that felt to compromise her agency. The criticism wasn't necessarily about the character being sensual or attractive. It was about whether she was being presented as a fully realised person or primarily as a visual attraction for the male lead. The debate also brought renewed attention to Kapoor's earlier comments about wanting to have a say in camera angles and not being sexualised without her consent. Director Buchi Babu Sana subsequently acknowledged the criticism and announced changes to certain portions of the film.


And that's an important distinction. Sensuality and objectification aren't interchangeable. A woman enjoying her sexuality, initiating intimacy, or choosing to dress a certain way is not automatically an example of the male gaze. Similarly, showing an attractive man on screen doesn't automatically make a scene an example of the female gaze. It comes down to perspective, context, and the space a character is given within the story.

Perhaps the reason we are still debating the male and female gaze is that representation is not just about who appears on screen, but how they are allowed to exist there. Audiences today are interested in relationships that feel emotionally believable, characters who have agency, and stories that acknowledge desire from more than one perspective. You can find Wolverine attractive and still want a man who knows how to communicate. You can enjoy a glamorous song sequence and still question why a female character has no storyline beyond it. The two conversations can coexist. The female gaze isn't here to dictate what women should find attractive. It simply makes room for more ways to look, feel, and desire.

Lead image: IMDb

Also read: Meghna Gulzar is guided by instinct in filmmaking and storytelling

Also read: The 'Indian aesthetic' on Pinterest isn’t really Indian

Read more!
Advertisement